High-Speed Steel (HSS) vs Shirogami #1

Detailed metallurgical comparison between High-Speed Tool Steel and White Paper Steel #1.

HIGH-SPEED-STEEL

High-Speed Steel (HSS)

High-Speed Tool Steel

Originally developed for machining applications, HSS (notably M2) has found its way into a niche of Japanese woodworking tools — particularly router bits, drill bits, and some specialty plane blades. Its extraordinary hot-hardness is irrelevant for woodworking, but its fine carbide structure and wear resistance make it compelling for specific applications where conventional carbon steel wears prematurely.

carbon0.78–0.88%chromium3.75–4.50%tungsten5.50–6.75%molybdenum4.50–5.50%vanadium1.75–2.20%
Sharpness
7
Edge Retention
9
Ease of Sharpening
4
Rust Resistance
5
SHIROGAMI-1

Shirogami #1

White Paper Steel #1

Pure high-carbon steel with minimal impurities. Takes a laser-like edge and is easy to sharpen, but more brittle than Aogami. The traditional choice of master woodworkers who demand the finest possible cutting edge and sharpen their tools with religious dedication. Rust forms overnight if neglected.

carbon1.25–1.35%
Sharpness
10
Edge Retention
7
Ease of Sharpening
9
Rust Resistance
2