Oroshigane vs Shirogami #1

Detailed metallurgical comparison between Smelted Folded Steel and White Paper Steel #1.

OROSHIGANE

Oroshigane

Smelted Folded Steel

Steel smelted and folded by individual blacksmiths in their own forge. Unlike Tamahagane from a centralized tatara, Oroshigane is entirely the creation of one smith — iron ore or scrap iron is smelted, refined, and folded to drive out slag. The result varies entirely by the smith's skill and chosen materials. Some legendary Oroshigane exceeds anything that can be purchased commercially.

carbonVaries — smith-dependent
Sharpness
9
Edge Retention
8
Ease of Sharpening
8
Rust Resistance
2
SHIROGAMI-1

Shirogami #1

White Paper Steel #1

Pure high-carbon steel with minimal impurities. Takes a laser-like edge and is easy to sharpen, but more brittle than Aogami. The traditional choice of master woodworkers who demand the finest possible cutting edge and sharpen their tools with religious dedication. Rust forms overnight if neglected.

carbon1.25–1.35%
Sharpness
10
Edge Retention
7
Ease of Sharpening
9
Rust Resistance
2